All states›New York›Oyster Bay

Ice Cream Shops in Oyster Bay, NY

9 ice cream shops in and around Oyster Bay, New York.

Oyster Bay has about 299,540 residents, which works out to 3.0 ice cream shops per 100,000 people. Population: U.S. Census Bureau, 2024 estimate.

Ice Cream Shops in Oyster Bay

The most complete and owner-verified listings first — hours, phone, website, services. No pay-to-play.

  1. Carvel

    317 Northwest Dr, Oyster Bay, NY 11735

    Mon-Sun 10am-10pm

    Ice cream cakes

    Soft serveVeganIce cream cakesMilkshakes
    Call Website Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

  2. Carvel

    2 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

    Mon-Sun 10am-10:30pm

    Call Website Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

  3. Baskin-Robbins

    159 Pine Hollow Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

    Mon-Sun 5am-10pm

    Locally owned

    Custard · Cookie sandwiches · Waffle cones

    Ice cream cakes
    Call Website Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

BEFORE YOU GO

Find your favourite frozen treat

Compare styles and choose how to serve your scoop.

All guides
CHOOSING

Gelato or ice cream?

Understand texture, serving style and the recipe behind the name.

Read the guide
DETAILS

Frozen yogurt or ice cream?

Look beyond the label to the flavour, ingredients and toppings.

Read the guide
BEFORE YOU GO

Choose your cone

Compare shape, size and the extras included in your order.

Read the guide

  1. Cold Stone Creamery

    297 N Broadway, Oyster Bay, NY 11753

    Cookie sandwiches

    Milkshakes
    Call Website Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

  2. Ralph's Famous Italian Ices

    850 Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11735

    Mon–Thu 12:00-22:00, Fri–Sat 12:00-23:00, Sun 12:00-22:00

    Since 1928

    Family-owned

    Sundaes

    Italian iceShaved iceHomemadeVegan
    Call Website Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

  3. Ralph's Famous Italian Ices

    633 Old Country Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11803

    Mon-Thu 12pm-10pm, Fri-Sat 12pm-11pm, Sun 12pm-10pm

    Since 1928

    Family-owned

    Sundaes

    Italian iceHomemadeVegan
    Call Website Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

  4. Ralph's Italian Ices

    Oyster Bay, NY 11771

    Mon–Thu 12:00-22:00, Fri–Sat 12:00-23:00, Sun 12:00-22:00

    Since 1928

    Family-owned

    Sundaes

    Italian iceHomemadeVegan
    Call Website Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

  5. Max & Mina's Pop Up

    96 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771-2360

    Call Website Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

  6. Häagen-Dazs

    350 S Broadway Unit 5, Oyster Bay, NY 11801

    Sundaes

    VeganMilkshakes
    Call Website Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

9ice cream shops
3.0per 100,000 residents
9with a phone
9with a website
6publish hours

Of the 9 ice cream shops listed in Oyster Bay, 9 give a phone number, 6 publish opening hours and 9 have a website. 5 are branches of national chains — Carvel (2), Baskin-Robbins (1), Cold Stone Creamery (1); the remaining 4 are independent. By what they offer: 5 offer vegan ice cream, 3 sell Italian ice, 3 make milkshakes. Most often named on their own websites: sundaes (4) and cookie sandwiches (2). The longest-running is Ralph's Famous Italian Ices, in business since 1928. 3 describe themselves as family-owned. The nearest bigger selection is Huntington with 21.

Oyster Bay 9 ice cream shops

Nearby in New York