Top 9 ice cream shops in Islip
Ranked by how complete and owner-verified the listing info is — hours, phone, website, services. No pay-to-play.
-
2Baskin-Robbins
1261 Sunrise Hwy, Islip, NY 11706
Locally owned
Custard · Cookie sandwiches · Waffle cones
BEFORE YOU GO
Find your favourite frozen treat
Compare styles and choose how to serve your scoop.
Gelato or ice cream?
Understand texture, serving style and the recipe behind the name.
Read the guide
Frozen yogurt or ice cream?
Look beyond the label to the flavour, ingredients and toppings.
Read the guide
Choose your cone
Compare shape, size and the extras included in your order.
Read the guide-
5sweetFrog
5640-35 Sunrise Hwy, Islip, NY 11782
-
6Hershey's Ice Cream
470 Union Blvd, Islip, NY 11795
-
7Mr Softee Store / Hamptons Soft Ice Cream Inc
195 Carleton Ave, Islip, NY 11730
-
9Culture Yogurt
353 Main St, Islip, NY 11751
Of the 12 ice cream shops listed in Islip, 12 give a phone number, 2 publish opening hours and 10 have a website. 5 are branches of national chains — Baskin-Robbins (2), Carvel (2), sweetFrog (1); the remaining 7 are independent. By what they offer: 4 make ice cream cakes, 4 make homemade ice cream, 3 serve soft serve. Most often named on their own websites: ice cream cakes (2), custard (2) and cookie sandwiches (2). The longest-running is Ralph's Italian Ices, in business since 1928. The nearest bigger selection is New York with 437.
All 3 other ice cream shops in Islip
Same order: the most complete listings first.
-
Baskin-Robbins
1750 Fifth Ave, Islip, NY 11706
Locally owned
Custard · Cookie sandwiches · Waffle cones